The Differences Between Buying A Second Home vs Investment Property

The Differences Between Buying A Second Home vs Investment Property

Did you know that rental property owners earn roughly 45% more than the median household income? The allure of venturing into property investment often comes from this very promise of substantial earnings. However, as you set foot on this journey, it's essential to understand the crucial distinctions between purchasing a second home vs an investment property. While they may seem similar on the surface, both have unique characteristics, requirements, and implications that prospective buyers must take into account.

Fast Facts About Investment Properties

To set the stage for our exploration, let's delve into some quick statistics about investment properties in the U.S.:
  • The U.S. boasts a sprawling network of about 48.2 million rental units, scattered across nearly 20 million properties, as per recent Census data.

  • Individual investors lay claim to the lion's share of rental properties, owning approximately 70%, while for-profit corporations control around 18% of properties, housing 45% of all rental units.

  • The final quarter of 2021 witnessed a staggering 75.3% of investment property purchases made in cash, as revealed by a Redfin analysis.

  • As of June 2022, the average monthly rent reached a new milestone, crossing $2,000. The rental market sees a broad spectrum of prices, from San Jose, California's steep $3,361 per month, to the more affordable $960 per month in Youngstown, Ohio.

Fast Facts About Second Homes

Let's turn the spotlight onto second homes now, examining some fascinating statistics from Gitnux:
  • As of 2018, there were approximately 1.5 million second homes across the U.S., demonstrating the popular trend of investing in second homes for a variety of purposes.

  • A remarkable surge in second home sales by 30% in 2020 signals an increasing demand for the autonomy and versatility that owning a second home can provide.

  • In an intelligent financial move, 24% of U.S. second home buyers in 2020 had plans to lease their property for short periods.

  • A growing trend towards co-ownership of second homes is apparent, with roughly 5% of second homes in the U.S. being shared ownership among multiple families.

Delving into Second Home Ownership

A second home, in essence, is an additional residential property that an individual or family buys apart from their primary residence. It can serve various purposes, such as a vacation retreat, a place for aging parents, or even a future primary home. Irrespective of the purpose, these homes are typically used by the owner and their family, and any generated rental income is usually not the main objective.

Exploring Investment Property Ownership

On the other hand, an investment property is purchased primarily for the purpose of generating income, often through renting it out. These properties can vary from single-family homes to large apartment buildings or even commercial properties. Unlike a second home, an investment property is not primarily intended for personal use, and the owner might never reside there.

How Mortgages Differ for Second Home and Investment Properties

Comparing Mortgage Rates

When it comes to mortgage rates, second homes and investment properties don't stand on equal footing. Typically, interest rates for second home mortgages are relatively lower than those for investment property mortgages. This is mainly due to the perceived higher risk associated with investment properties.

Dissecting Down Payments

The down payment criteria also exhibit a significant difference between a second home and an investment property. Generally, second home buyers can expect lower down payment requirements compared to investment property buyers. This disparity is, once again, attributed to the higher risk associated with investment properties.

Understanding Qualifying Requirements

Getting approved for a mortgage also involves different qualifying requirements for a second home vs an investment property. For investment property loans, lenders might require higher credit scores and lower debt-to-income ratios compared to second home loans. In addition, prospective rental income may not be considered when qualifying for a second home mortgage, unlike for an investment property mortgage.

Rental Income Considerations

Rental income is another pivotal factor that differentiates a second home from an investment property. While some second home owners may occasionally rent out their homes, it's not their primary motive. On the other hand, investment property owners buy properties with the express purpose of generating rental income.

Is it Wrong to Claim Your Investment Property as a Second Home?

The Consequences of Converting Your Second Home into an Investment Property Post-Purchase

Misrepresenting an investment property as a second home can lead to serious implications, including accusations of mortgage fraud. This is because lenders typically offer more favorable terms for second homes given their lower risk compared to investment properties. Therefore, it's always crucial to be upfront about your intentions for the property when applying for a loan.

About Team Banx

Behind this article is the hardworking Team Banx, a dynamic group of independent agents who banded together with the mission of delivering unprecedented value and service to their clients. If you're looking to buy or sell a home or have any questions about the New York real estate market, don't hesitate to reach out to Team Banx today.


Work With Us

Building community in the Hudson Valley as the area's most innovative real estate team. Whether you’re searching for your first home, your next home, or looking to sell your home and move we are all looking forward to serving you.

Follow Me on Instagram